An open inguinal hernia repair has been the gold standard. Hundreds of thousands of these operations have been done worldwide. The technique is simple and the recurrence rate with a mesh is low. In addition, this can be done under local anaesthesia.

The reason for the MESH is that it will provide an anatomical repair and provide a scaffold for the body's scar tissue to grow on(this gives long term strength to the repair and reduces the rate of recurrence)

The repair is done TENSION-FREE - the mesh is secured with staples/sutures to the muscles in a way which does not pull on the muscle(If the mesh is sutured too tightly onto the muscles under tension, there may be pain on coughing/straining)

INCISION LENGTH - A cut is made over the inguinal canal - the length of the cut depends on the thickness of the body fat. In a lean person, it is about 3-4cm in the author's hands. (This is nearly the same length as the sum of the length of 3 incisions needed in a laparoscopic repair. However a lot of surgeons who do hernia repairs are not able to so via a short open incision and the patients end up with a long scar - hence the current trend away from open inguinal hernia repairs)

Occassionally a mesh plug may be used to as well to patch the "hole" in the abdominal wall where the hernia is popping out from.

Benefits of having a Hernia Repair

Planned elective surgery is much safer than leaving a hernia until a complication happen.

Risks of not having surgery:

1. Hernia may get bigger - as it gets bigger, there is more likelyhood that the intestine will come out in the hernia as well.

2. Risks of contents of the hernia becoming trapped and blocked or gangrenous(if there is bowel in it, the bowel wall may die and burst causing life-threatening peritonitis). Treatment of the latter would mean a more extensive bowel resection and a weaker repair especially if a mesh is contraindicated in the presence of infection

Local anaesthesia & sedation vs General anaesthesia

This should be discussed with your surgeon and anaesthetist before your operation.

Benefits of local anaesthesia and sedation: 1. For patients with serious heart or lung problems, there is a significantly lower anaesthetic risk having a repair under LA and sedation. 2. Patient is awake throughout the procedure - some patients are afraid of being put under a general anaesthesia. 3. Quicker recovery as the patient is given a lower dose of the anaesthetic drugs when compared to a general anaesthesia(although this benefit is minimal in someone who is fit and well - ie a matter of minutes)

Benefits of general anaesthesia - some patients prefer to be asleep for the procedure(Local anaethesia will also be injected during the operation)


The anaesthetist will insert a drip for administration of drugs and fluids. The site of the surgery is marked before the operation and the site shaved.

A short incision is made over the hernia. The hernia sac is freed from the surrounding tissues and its contents are inspected and pushed back in or the fat may be resected . The defect may then be closed with direct sutures posteriorly. A polypropelene mesh is cut into a special shape and stapled down with Absorbtack(absorbable staples)

Sometimes a mesh plug would be used. The mesh provides additional strength to the repair. The mesh (which is permanent and non-absorbable) allows scar tissue to grow within its holes hence increasing the strength of the abdominal wall it is covering.

Average operating time is around 30 minutes, No muscle relaxants needed.

After Your Operation

You are encouraged to move you legs and flex and extend your ankles as soon as you can once in the recovery ward. Once fully alert, you can eat and drink.

Pain-killers - It is recommended that Panadeine Forte be taken regularly for the first few days together with a non-steroidal anti-inflammatory medications(eg Brufen) (Provided there are no contraindications to the latter eg peptic ulcer disease, severe asthma)

Bowel motions - It is important to drink plenty of fluids and take lots of fibre(fruits and vegetables) after the operation to avoid constipation.

Dressings - Dissolving sutures is usually used on the wound. Sometimes adhesive strips are placed across the wound for additional closure strength. A waterproof dressing is usually placed over the top of the wound. This should be left in place for around 2 weeks. The adhesive strips under (Steristrips) can be removed another week later.

RECOVERY - You are encourged to walk and do light activities as soon as you get home. Take care when you get out of bed(avoid straining). It is advisable not to do any heavy lifting for 4-6 weeks.

BACK TO WORK - this varies from person to person. For office work - about 1-2 weeks. For manual work - it slightly longer. (The author has had self-employed patients return to work lifting 10kg boxes from the 3rd day without any problems with the repair)

DRIVING - it is best to not drive for at least a week(the risk is of pain in the wound when braking)



One reason some surgeons recommend laparoscopic surgery is that there is supposedly less pain in the immediate post-op period. However in the author's  hands, pain post-op is similar or less via open inguinal hernia repair(also there is no shoulder tip pain or pain in the belly button region often seen in a laparoscopic repair) Also a lot of surgeons do not get enough training in doing open inguinal hernia repairs through a short incisions and hence are not able to do them well. 

On the downside, a general anaesthesia with MUSCLE RELAXANTS is needed for a laparoscopic inguinal hernia repair. In addition the special instruments and equipment needed for the laparoscopic repair is costly(about an additional $1000-$1500) 

Risks specific to laparoscopic surgery include: 

(i) Injury to organs near the hernia site such as the intestine and bladder
(ii) Massive haemorrhage from injury to major blood vessels 
(iii) Gas embolism - from the carbon dioxide gas used to insufflate; this can be life threatening
(iv) Swelling of scrotum due to seroma - may need decompression postop
(v) New hernia - at any of the laparoscopic port sites(usually 3 keyhole sized cuts are made)
(vi) Adhesions causing bowel obstruction
(vii) Subcutaneous emphysema - gas tracking in soft tissue causing swelling under skin from chest to scrotum
(viii) Injury to nerves from pigtail metal staples used to tack mesh down - causing postop pain
Studies have also shown a HIGHER RISK OF HERNIA RECURRENCE from a laparoscopic repair compared with an open mesh repair(N Engl J Med 2004; 350:1819-1827). 
The is also a potentially higher risk of blood clots developing from the combination of the laparoscopic technique and general anaesthesia. (The author has also noticed an increase in port site hernias from the laparoscopic port sites especially in the umbilical area)

2. REPAIR WITHOUT MESH - there is more tension on the muscle and more postop pain. This is only recommended in paediatric hernias and in the presence of infection where a mesh is contraindicated. 3. OBSERVATION alone - if the hernia does not cause any symptom, the risk of complication is around 0.2% each year in a man. Certainly if the hernia is seen only on ultrasound and there is no lump - surgery is not neccessary. Also in cases of groin pain alone with hernia seen only on ultrasound - surgery is unlikely to relieve the groin pain(this is usually due to musculo-skeletal causes)

Risks of any inguinal hernia repair - both from open or laparoscopic method

1. Urinary retention - usually a temporary problem and more common in elderly men who have enlarged prostate. May need a temporary urinary catheter. There risks is low if local anaesthesia has been effectively injected

2. Wound problems -

(i) Wound infection (1%) : may need antibotics

(ii) Bleeding into wound/ bruising around wound ( 3%)

(iii) Scar/keloid - the scar may thicken and be prominent

3. Testicular problems - swelling of the testicles/scrotum, testicular pain. Injury or damage to the vas(sperm tube) - especially in a recurrent hernia repair. Damage to the blood vessels to the testicles - this may cause testicular ischaemia and testicular pain.(the risks are increased in a recurrent hernia repair). Change in position of the testicle - the testicle on that site of surgery may sit slightly higher in the scrotum after the operation.

3. Damage to bowel/bladder and blood vessels(rare - more so in a laparoscopic repair where one can get serious life threatening vessel injury). Development of adhesions in the bowel that is pushed back in.

4. Recurrence of hernia (<1-3%) : Higher in laparoscopic inguinal hernia repair

5. Unexpected findings - eg bowel cancer in the hernia - this may mean having a bigger operation than planned

6. Ongoing pain and discomfort - sometimes this is due to a nerve in the groin being cut or trapped in a stitch/staple or caught in scar tissue.

General risks of any operation 

There are risks with any operation which may also happen with a hernia repair.

1. Deep venous thrombosis (Blood clots in the deep veins of the leg) with risk of pulmonary embolism (clot may break off and go to the lung - this can be life-threatening). The risks are less if local anaesthesia is used instead of general anaesthesia and if the operating time is shorter.

2. Lung collapse. Chest infection. Heart attack, stroke and death.

Also in general, smokers and obese patients have increased risk of developing complications.

Mr LP Cheah is an expert in inguinal hernia repairs. He has learned his techniques from a number of teachers from Britain, Australia and Canada including Mr Maurice Brygel (Melbourne Hernia Clinic) and Mr David Fossard (England). He is one of the busiest hernia surgeons in Melbourne & Victoria using the  mini-open technique and has performed over 2000 hernia repairs.